How to keep cold email out of spam: SPF, DKIM and DMARC, the Gmail and Yahoo sender rules, warming up a new mailbox, daily limits and list hygiene.

Migaru6 min read

Cold email deliverability is whether your outbound email reaches the inbox rather than spam, or isn’t accepted at all. It rests on four things: a sending domain that proves who it is (SPF, DKIM and DMARC), a sending reputation built up slowly (warm-up and modest daily limits), a clean list (few bounces), and email people don’t mark as spam (relevant, easy to opt out of). Get those right and the copy gets its chance to work.

Since 2024, Gmail and Yahoo have enforced sender requirements that turn some of this from good practice into the price of entry. This guide covers what they ask for, and what to do about the rest.

Authenticate your sending domain

A receiving server asks three questions of an email from a stranger, and each is answered by a DNS record on your domain:

  • SPF: is this server allowed to send mail for the domain? A TXT record listing your mail provider.
  • DKIM: did the domain sign this message? A public key published under a selector your provider chooses, such as “google” for Google Workspace.
  • DMARC: what should happen to mail that fails, and where should reports go? A TXT record named _dmarc on your domain. Start with a policy of “none” to monitor, and tighten it to “quarantine” or “reject” once reports show everything legitimate passes.

All three are set at your domain’s DNS host, not in your email app. Your mail provider’s help pages give the exact values.

The Gmail and Yahoo sender requirements

Since February 2024, Google and Yahoo have required every sender to authenticate with SPF or DKIM and to keep spam complaints low. Bulk senders, which Google defines as sending around 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail addresses, must also:

  • Authenticate with both SPF and DKIM, and publish a DMARC record.
  • Send from a domain that aligns with the one SPF or DKIM authenticates.
  • Offer one-click unsubscribe on marketing and subscribed messages, and honour it promptly.
  • Keep the spam complaint rate their users report below 0.3%, and ideally well below it.

Few cold email programmes reach the bulk threshold from one domain, but the direction is clear: mail that can’t prove where it came from, or that people complain about, isn’t delivered. Google’s email sender guidelines are the source to check for changes.

Use separate mailboxes for cold email

Many teams send cold email from a second domain, or several mailboxes on one, rather than from the addresses their customers and colleagues write to. If a campaign goes badly, the damage lands on the outbound domain, not on the mail your business runs on.

Make the second domain obviously yours, such as a short variant of your company name, give it a real website that redirects to your main one, and authenticate it exactly as you would your main domain.

Warm up new mailboxes

A new domain or mailbox has no reputation, and a mailbox that goes from silence to a hundred cold emails a day looks exactly like spam. Email warm-up builds reputation first: the mailbox sends a small, rising number of ordinary emails to other mailboxes that open them, reply to some, and move them out of spam if they landed there. Receiving servers learn that mail from the domain is wanted.

Warm-up works best alongside a slow start to real sending: a handful of cold emails on the first day, rising a few a day, rather than the full volume at once. Keep warm-up running after you start sending, so the mailbox’s history isn’t only cold email.

How many cold emails to send a day

There is no published safe number, and anyone quoting one is guessing. What holds up is this: keep each mailbox’s volume modest and steady, spread sends through the working day rather than in bursts, and add mailboxes to grow volume rather than pushing one mailbox harder. Watch bounces, replies and spam placement, and slow down when any of them gets worse.

Keep your list clean

  • Verify addresses before sending. Bounces tell providers you don’t know who you are writing to.
  • Stop at the first bounce. Never send a second step to an address that bounced.
  • Stop at the first reply, for the person and often for their whole company. Two colleagues getting the same sequence after one of them answered reads as spam because it is.
  • Honour opt-outs everywhere, not only in the campaign they came from. Keep a blocklist every campaign reads.
  • Remove people who have left, which an automatic reply often tells you before a bounce does.

Write email people don’t report

  • Relevance beats volume. One email that plainly concerns the reader’s job is worth ten that could have gone to anyone.
  • Plain text, few links. Heavy formatting, images and many links look like marketing, and are treated like it.
  • Make opting out easy. A clear line or link saying how to stop hearing from you costs fewer replies than a spam report costs reputation.
  • Track less. Open-tracking pixels and rewritten links are signals some filters weigh, and opens are an unreliable measure anyway now that many mail apps load images automatically. Measure replies.

Cold email law differs by country, from opt-out rules in the United States to stricter rules on contacting individuals in parts of Europe. This is not legal advice; check the rules where your recipients are.

How Migaru handles deliverability

On Growth, Migaru’s Outreach sends the cold campaigns you write and launch from mailboxes connected for the purpose, Google, Microsoft or any SMTP and IMAP, never your everyday inbox. Each mailbox’s card reads its domain’s SPF, DKIM and DMARC records and says what is missing and where to add it.

Unless you change them, each mailbox starts at 10 emails on its first day, adds 3 a day up to 30, and sends them ten minutes apart, while warm-up trades up to 20 ordinary emails a day with mailboxes at other domains that read them, rescue them from spam and answer some. Campaigns send on weekdays in working hours, with an unsubscribe link, and count opens and clicks only if you turn that on.

A reply, a bounce or an unsubscribe stops the campaign for that person, and by default an answer from one person stops it for their whole company. An unsubscribe also marks them Do not contact and adds them to the blocklist, and nobody marked Do not contact is written to. Answers land in one inbox, labelled as they arrive. Follow-ups, sequences and Outreach has the details, and AI pipeline generation the rest of outbound.

Frequently asked questions

Why are my cold emails going to spam?

Usually because the sending domain isn’t fully authenticated with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, the mailbox is new or sending too much too fast, too many addresses bounce, or recipients mark the emails as spam. Fix authentication first, then volume and list quality.

What is email warm-up?

Building a new mailbox’s sending reputation by having it send a small, rising number of ordinary emails to mailboxes that open, answer and rescue them from spam, so receiving servers learn its mail is wanted before it sends anything cold.

How long does it take to warm up a new email domain?

Plan on a few weeks of warm-up and a slow ramp before full volume. Keep warm-up running after you start sending, and slow down whenever bounces or spam placement get worse.

Do I need SPF, DKIM and DMARC for cold email?

Yes. Gmail and Yahoo require every sender to authenticate with at least SPF or DKIM, and bulk senders to have SPF, DKIM and a DMARC record. Mail from a domain without them is far more likely to land in spam or be refused.

Should I send cold email from my main domain?

Many teams use a separate domain or dedicated mailboxes for cold email, so a campaign that goes badly can’t hurt the reputation of the domain their everyday business mail depends on.

See what Migaru does with your customer record.